Witch Week

It’s Witch Week! Actually, this is my first year participating in Witch Week which is hosted by Lory at The Emerald City Book Review. The theme this year is ‘Dreams of Arthur’ and I have decided to read The Crystal Cave by Mary Stewart which is told from Merlin’s point of view.  One thing the book blogging community does well is to encourage others to read more widely. Honestly, I don’t read much fantasy and I may not have picked up this book if I were not participating in this event. However, I am so glad I read this book because I really enjoyed it!



 Summary from Goodreads:  Fifth century Britain is a country of chaos and division after the Roman withdrawal. This is the world of young Merlin, the illegitimate child of a South Wales princess who will not reveal to her son his father’s true identity. Yet Merlin is an extraordinary child, aware at the earliest age that he possesses a great natural gift – the Sight. Against a background of invasion and imprisonment, wars and conquest, Merlin emerges into manhood, and accepts his dramatic role in the New Beginning – the coming of King Arthur.

The Crystal Cave is the first book in a trilogy that is told from Merlin’s perspective.  This book, which is narrated by Merlin, opens the story when he is just six years old. We read along as he grows and learns how to use his unusual gift: The Sight. We journey with him through his adolescence where he meets his father, are held in rapt attention as he makes legendary prophesies and witness the dangerous lengths he went to in helping to bring forth King Arthur.

This book is more than just setting the stage for the main event though, which is the coming of King Arthur. Here, we are introduced to the young Merlin: to the boy and adolescent before he becomes the legend we all know him to be. We read how he is influenced by The Sight and how he grows into young adulthood. I enjoyed reading about the ordinary, logical aspects of his personality that are often lost in the legend. It’s interesting how stories evolve over time making someone larger than life. Even in this book, we read how the stories and songs about Merlin were creating a false- although, magically fantastic – picture of him, until they barely resembled the real story.

I liked how the legendary, almost supernatural side of Merlin could be logically explained. There was a valid reason his mother never told anyone who his father was, there was a mathematical precision to moving the stones at Stonehenge and his prophesies with Vortigern show someone quick of mind without removing the prophetic mystery that makes Merlin who he is.

I was disappointed that Merlin’s mother and father never got the chance to see each other again after so many years apart. It would have been nice for them to connect again, even if it was only to be thankful for Merlin. I wonder, if they had the chance to meet again, what would have happened? His mother really suffered in refusing to name Merlin’s father. Did she love Ambrosius? Or was she protecting someone? Her son? Or, perhaps, herself? That is open to interpretation and although I want to say that she loved Ambrosius (and who knows, maybe she did), but, the fact remains that she was a mom, and so, was most likely protecting her son. Then again, it could have been all of the above. 

For me, one of the most interesting scenes was when he prophesied before Vortigern. This whole scene from witnessing his mother reveal his father’s identity – in a very engrossing way, –  through the prophesies of the dragons and becoming ‘Vortigern’s prophet’. I was completely absorbed in this story.  I was all ears, in a manner of speaking, as his mother told the court about Merlin’s father, then later, I was eager to read how he would get out of the predicament he found himself in. It was great storytelling!

As someone who doesn’t read much in this genre, I thought this was a great book to begin my adventures into fantasy because, for me, the story wasn’t so fantastic and magical as to be unbelievable. At times I found myself reading this as though it were historical fiction- my favorite genre! – which speaks well of Stewart’s writing. The magical and supernatural were balanced with a logic and rationality that kept me reading. We read that Merlin was a lonely and odd child who grew up amid rumors of an unholy union between his demonic father and Christian mother.  His unusual gift could be viewed as Satanic power that stems from his father (Actually, I was surprised to find out who really passed on that gift). And so, it’s not difficult to believe that this would have shaped him as an outsider going into young adulthood. 

This book is very much a story of self discovery for Merlin; he needs to find and make his own way in life and he does just that. This is Merlin before he becomes a legend and before King Arthur.

Thank you Lory for hosting this event! It allowed me to stretch myself and broaden my reading horizons. Now, I want to finish reading this trilogy and see how this story plays out.

13 thoughts on “Witch Week

  1. Thank you, KIA. It was a good story, well told. Stewart did a wonderful job of drawing me into this story and making the story of Merlin come alive. I highly recommend It!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Witch Week — My Book-a-logue | Fantasy Sources: Art, Gifts, Ideas, Article Resources, News

  3. I read this eons ago but remember little about it. At the time I’d read much of Stewart’s source materials, including the 12th-century Geoffrey of Monmouth’s pseudohistory The History of the Kings of Britain; I was more interested in how she’d humanised what were fantastic legendary figures than in the storytelling. So I was pleased your review highlighted for me what was its abiding strength, the rationalising of what were otherwise quite preposterous plotlines!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I understand that Geoffrey of Monmouth’s work was very popular even in it’s day. It seems that people just dont get tired of reading about King Arthur. I mean, even today, there are books, movies and TV shows about Arthur and Merlin. I enjoyed reading about Merlin in this book and it will be interesting to read how Stewart presents King Arthur in the next 2 books!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thanks! That’s interesting that you found Mary Stewart through book blogging. I’m glad I found her too. Now, I would like to finish this series and read how she fleshes out King Arthur.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Cape Cod Scenes, Reading Adventures, and Neighborhood Turkeys | Sheila Hurst

  7. I’ve always been intrigued by stories of Merlin and will have to read this one now – thank you! I’m sorry it’s taken me a while to get back to the blog and giveaway, but I wanted to let you know that you’ve won a signed copy of Ocean Echoes. I sent a message to your WordPress email address and will just need your street address to send that to you.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I saw this post during Witch Week, but I was right in the middle of reading it myself and I didn’t want to hear any spoilers until I was done. And then I forgot about it!

    I really enjoyed reading this book and I like your comments. There were so many times that I was certain Merlin was going to die, but then I remembered he couldn’t because there were more books in the series 🙂

    I was very taken with all the historical aspects, or what we know about them and Stewart’s fleshing out such rich characters from her research.

    I was given a copy of the next book in the series and if I get some down time over the holidays I hope to read that.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Hi Laurie. No worries, I wouldn’t have wanted any spoilers while I was reading this book either. I enjoyed this book and Stewart did such a great job of making him real and human, rather than presenting him as the fantastic legend that usually comes to mind when thinking of Merlin.

    How fun that someone gave you a copy of the next book! I want to read the whole trilogy and find out how she brings Arthur to life as well. I hope you find some time to read it over the holidays and have fun with it!! 🙂


What would you add?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s